Climate warning
Image of B Lab

B Lab

Climate warning

Should B Corp Stop Certifying Companies Chasing Fossil Fuel Investments

Investors Green Claims Tarnished By Funding Oil Exploration off Vulnerable Islands By Nick Nuttall An investment house, certified by B Corp is among some big-name investors who are triggering outrage among environmentalists, fishermen and local and regional tourism interests by backing oil drilling off the coast of The Bahamas. Protestors say oil drilling in these pristine Caribbean waters flies in the face of international action to curb global warming under the Paris Climate Change Agreement and makes a mockery of the Bahamian government’s decision to declare a climate emergency. They are also alarmed at the prospects of oil spills and oil related disasters with the risks to fish, coral reefs and livelihoods. The test drilling, which began in December after being given the green light by the government, is being carried out by the Bahamas Petroleum Company (BPC) which is listed in London. Shareholders in the company include Hargreaves Lansdown Asset Management based in Bristol, England and Barclays Wealth, a part of Barclays Bank that serves high net worth clients. Barclay’s announced in 2020 its aim to be a net zero bank by 2050 by aligning its investments with the Paris Agreement and phasing out funding to fossil fuel companies. Another investor is Lombard Odier Asset Management, part of the private Swiss bank, Lombard Odier, which is a certified B Corporation. It is investing over £11 million in the oil drilling venture. According to the B Corp web site: “Certified B Corporations are business that meet the highest standards of verified social and environmental performance, public transparency and legal accountability to balance profit and purpose”. The citation on the B Corp web site for Lombard Odier says “sustainability is at the heart of everything they do….their ambition is to secure a sustainable future for generations to come”. The Eyewitness news web site in the Bahamas a few days ago reported that they had asked for a statement from Lombard Odier who had now expressed ‘regret’ with their involvement and that they are “taking the necessary actions to address it”. Campaigners say the company should never have been involved in the first place and are only back tracking after their involvement became open to public scrutiny. They are now looking to Lombard Odier to make good on their promise to act with clear and concrete action and assurances this slip-up does not happen again and will ask the B Corp network to take a "long hard look" into why they continue to certify companies making fossil fuel investments. There is also now confusion over whether the Bahamas Petroleum Company has sufficient insurance cover in the event of a catastrophe. The company has claimed that Lloyds of London has underwritten the insurance. But campaigners with Our Island Our Future coalition claim they have asked Lloyds directly. First Lloyds said they have no record of cover having been issued in the Lloyds underwriting market. But later agreed that there was cover but declined to detail how much. The issue of insurance is not only alarming local campaigners but also ones in Florida and elsewhere in the Caribbean. The good news for campaigners is that a Supreme Court judge has granted environmentalists leave to seek a judicial review of the government’s approvals for BPC to drill an exploratory well in Bahamian waters. However the courts have not called a halt to the test drilling which is currently underway. It has been discovered that BPC has not yet settled with the government regarding past-due license fees, so potential future benefits to the country are also in question. The Bahamas is highly vulnerable to climate change and extreme weather events. In 2019 it was hit by hurricane Dorian which, according to the Inter-American Development Bank, caused US $3.4 billion or a quarter of the country’s GDP. It may take ten years for the economy to recover. Casuarina McKinney-Lambert, Executive Director of the Bahamas Reef Environment Educational Foundation, said: “Environmentally and economically this oil drilling makes no sense and the investors, especially those who talk the green talk, need to walk the green walk, and walk away from this disaster in the making”. “We need the government to revoke these and any future licenses to drill in the pristine Bahamian waters. Public consultation has been next to zero and it is the people of the Bahamas that will assume all of the risk, and any benefits would be exported out of the country,” she said. Ms McKinney-Lambert said it was also unfathomable that the government could be pressing ahead with this activity as world leaders ready to attend President Biden’s climate Summit on Earth Day in April and nations look to the next, UK-hosted, UN climate conference in November, to step up climate ambition. “The Bahamas facilitating oil drilling contributes to our own destruction. This is akin to being in a sinking ship and begging others to help while simultaneously burning our flotation vests and drilling holes in the hull,” she added. Yesterday the BPC announced that the drilling has not hit large quantities of oil. Ms McKinney-Lambert said it was hoped this might bring an end to this sorry story in the Bahamas: "We now need a full ban on any future oil exploration in Bahamian waters". But BPC noted they will be reviewing their licenses while continuing oil activities in other parts of the Caribbean including Trinidad and Tobago.

Do you agree?

37 more agrees trigger social media ads

  • Charles Njoroge

    161 w

    Alot should be done to STOP IT!

    • B Lab

      161 w

      B Lab is aware of the issue and is engaging with Lombard Odier to assess the situation in accordance with our complaint procedures, which you can learn more about here: https://bcorporation.net/complaints B Lab is committed to credible and meaningful action by companies to address the climate emergency and driving companies to commit to net zero emissions by 2030 (https://www.bcorpclimatecollective.org/net-zero-2030). In addition to being required to recertify every three years in order to ensure companies remain in compliance with our standards, B Lab also has mechanisms in place to review particular issues in between a company’s certification terms to determine whether additional action may be required. At the core of B Corp Certification requirements is the B Impact Assessment, a comprehensive measure of a company’s social and environmental performance, which includes a series of questions specific to the finance industry on topics such as investment screening criteria, assets under management, shareholder advocacy, etc. Companies are required to achieve an overall verified score of an 80 to be a Certified B Corporation. In addition to this scored component, there is also a separate review for practices or controversies that may affect a company’s eligibility, which you can learn about here: https://bcorporation.net/controversial-issues While to date companies have not been required to have specific minimum practices in order to achieve the score of 80, in recognition of our Declaration of a Climate Emergency (https://www.bcorpclimatecollective.org/news/cop25-b-corp-commitment-netzero2030), and the pressing issues the world is facing today, B Lab has also initiated a review of our certification requirements (https://bcorporation.net/news/message-b-corp-community-and-all-interested-parties) with the potential of adding in specific minimum practices on key issues. An initial consultation phase of this process has just concluded, and will continue to be developed over time. Like B Corps, B Lab strives to be continually improving and learning, and your feedback is always welcome. Best, The Team at B Lab

      6
      • Ingmar Rentzhog

        161 w

        Thanks for answering and taking this issue seriously B Lab. We can't hide behind good social impact if we destroy the planet we live on.

        7
        • Nicholas Nuttall

          161 w

          Thanks for responding B Corp/B Lab, i think the worry for many concerned about this particular case is the way the company concerned and its involvement in funding oil drilling in a highly vulnerable country's coastal waters, was that without the enormous efforts of campaigners, the world might not have known which raises questions of deep, green washing. Please put this in mind as your refine your review!

          8
        • Marco Rodzynek

          162 w

          Great work !!!! Thank you. The real greenwashing is happening through these big logo rubbing entities. The reality is looking very different. If you want to be noble BCorp, you better have some noble rules, otherwise the whole things looks like a bit of a useless exercise. What does BCorp stand for?

          7
          • Nicholas Nuttall

            162 w

            Would be good if we could collectively get this to next level and generate some social media ads to really put some fire under B Corp — any advice to do this from more experienced colleagues

            5
            • Marco Rodzynek

              162 w

              We will for sure!

              3
            • Douglas Marett

              163 w

              B Corp addresses many parts together of sustainability in Environment, Social, and Governance. So a single negative environmental impact will not disqualify if there are many more positive impacts. However, B Corp does adjust the methodology periodically, and people may submit a suggested change as well Certification is also periodic, every three years, so a company can be removed as a B Corp if they don't meet the threshold.

              8
              • Bel Jacobs

                161 w

                I wonder if funding oil exploration could be considered as cancelling out all other positive initiatives. It feels extremely counter intuitive.

                2
              • We Don't Have Time

                163 w

                Dear Nicholas Nuttall Thank you for getting your climate warning to level 2! We have reached out to B Lab and asked for a response. I will keep you updated on any progress! /Adam We Don't Have Time

                • Muhammad Fahd Khan

                  163 w

                  This is a big ignorance on part of B Corp. They should never certify such organisations. @Connon_Lascelles has raised a good point. I would say that there should be a system to cancel the certification if a company decides to chose unsustainable investments/practices after getting certification

                  6
                  • Connor Lascelles

                    163 w

                    Wow thanks for sharing. Does B Corp have any systems in place to re-assess companies climate action? What happens if they certify someone and it later turns out that this company is acting against the mission of B Corp?

                    5
                    • Johannes Luiga

                      163 w

                      This is not ok. Thanks for sharing!

                      5
                      • Abraham Davenport

                        163 w

                        Any government official who allows oil or gas exploration should be forced to debate their own children on live television about why this is a good or bad idea. If they have no children I'm sure we could find some kids who would be willing to debate them.

                        8
                        Welcome, let's solve the climate crisis together
                        Post youtube preview with preloading
                        youtube overlay

                        Write or agree to climate reviews to make businesses and world leaders act. It’s easy and it works.

                        Write a climate review

                        Voice your opinion on how businesses and organizations impact the climate.
                        0 trees planted

                        One tree is planted for every climate review written to an organization that is Open for Climate Dialogue™.

                        Download the app

                        We plant a tree for every new user.

                        AppleAndroid