Climate warning
Image of Olaf Scholz

Olaf Scholz

Climate warning

Germany: "Betrayal of trust" - combustion engine blockade frustrates EU partners

Federal Transport Minister Volker Wissing (FDP liberals) repeatedly emphasizes that the EU Commission must submit a proposal as to how new private cars that use climate-neutral, synthetic fuels, so-called e-fuels, can still be registered after 2035. Source: dpa
Federal Transport Minister Volker Wissing (FDP) repeatedly emphasizes that the EU Commission must submit a proposal as to how new private cars that use climate-neutral, synthetic fuels, so-called e-fuels, can still be registered after 2035.
Actually, the extensive end of combustion engines from 2035 in the EU should have been decided long ago. But Transport Minister Wissing stopped the project in the last few meters. Heavy criticism comes from Brussels.
The ongoing German blockade of the planned end for new combustion engines from 2035 is met with incomprehension and horror among European partners. EU diplomats in Brussels speak of a breach of trust and criticize the government's disagreement in Berlin. The leadership of Chancellor Olaf Scholz (SPD) is also being questioned and comparisons with Viktor Orban's Hungarian government are being made.
"We think it's a breach of trust," says a diplomat from the German Press Agency about the German approach. The negotiations had taken place in the usual manner, objections could have been raised earlier – and German concerns had been taken into account. "One would wish that the coalition's internal disputes would be resolved beforehand."
In the future, one will always ask oneself “what an agreement with Germany is worth at all”. Perhaps other countries would also come up with the idea of behaving in the same way. Her conclusion: "This is all extremely questionable."
Because it should actually have been decided since Tuesday what politicians, car manufacturers and other observers had been assuming for months anyway: that in the EU from 2035 only new cars may be sold that do not emit any greenhouse gases during operation. Negotiators from the European Parliament and the EU states had already agreed on this in October. In November, the permanent representatives of the member states confirmed the outcome of the negotiations with German approval, and the European Parliament approved it in mid-February.
The very last step in the long legislative process was planned for last Tuesday: the final approval of the EU states - a formality that normally does not require debate.
Because there were already enough opportunities to bring in your own wishes, as several diplomats emphasize. In the summer, for example, when the EU countries coordinated their negotiating position. Or later, when talks with Parliament were underway. But now to register concerns - "that's pretty unusual," says an EU diplomat. The other countries were very surprised, says another diplomat. Other representatives of member states in Brussels are far less diplomatic about the approach, which the FDP in particular is accused of.
Because it was only at the end of February, about a week before the planned vote, that FDP Transport Minister Volker Wissing suddenly expressed concerns via "Bild" - and threatened in the newspaper not to agree to the result after months of negotiations. Since then, Wissing and FDP leader Christian Lindner have repeatedly emphasized that the EU Commission must submit a proposal as to how new private cars that use climate-neutral, synthetic fuels, so-called e-fuels, can still be registered after 2035.
Above all, the FDP argues that all technological options must be kept open for climate-neutral mobility. With e-fuels, combustion engines can theoretically be operated in a climate-friendly manner, but their production is relatively energy-intensive.
Under pressure from the FDP, the federal government had already negotiated an amendment to the planned law in the summer of 2022, according to which the EU Commission should submit a proposal for CO2-neutral fuels. However, the Brussels authorities are of the opinion that this cannot be aimed at private cars, but only at special vehicles such as fire engines. And so the federal government is currently blocking the law that has been negotiated - together with Poland, Italy and Bulgaria. The vote has been postponed indefinitely.
Is Germany a reliable partner?
The German traffic light coalition itself does not agree on this. The FDP and SPD Chancellor Scholz see the commission to be responsible for presenting a new proposal. The Green-led Ministry of the Environment, on the other hand, criticizes the blockade of the Ministry of Transport. Minister Steffi Lemke warns: "Germany should remain a reliable partner among EU partners."
But the damage has long been done. Spain's Deputy Prime Minister, Teresa Ribera, recently warned of scenarios in which other governments could do similar things on other issues. Another EU diplomat says such behavior is expected from the Hungarian government under Viktor Orban, but that Germany has a special responsibility in the EU.
Former Chancellor Angela Merkel understood that a well-functioning EU was in the best interest of Germany as the largest member and the largest economy. "Scholz has not yet understood this and seems to act more as a national minister than as Chancellor," emphasizes the diplomat. However, in view of the global situation, Germany cannot afford to “pursue a narrow-minded national approach in the EU”.
The diplomat also points out that it is not the first time that the traffic light government in Brussels has been perceived as divided. He mentions, for example, the negotiations on better working conditions for platform workers, in which the EU states were recently unable to determine a position because the traffic light did not find a line.
A senior EU diplomat said earlier this year that Germany is the only country that can afford to represent three positions on the same issue at the same time - depending on which party you are talking to.

Do you agree?

16 more agrees trigger contact with the recipient

  • Tabitha Kimani

    65 w

    Its unbelievable how one country/person in a union can hold others hostage.

    • Joseph Githinji

      65 w

      This is trailing development towards achieving a sustainable future. The minister must rethink his moves and reverse this hypocritical decision. EU members has a responsibility to continue fighting this decision

      Welcome, let's solve the climate crisis together
      Post youtube preview with preloading
      youtube overlay

      Write or agree to climate reviews to make businesses and world leaders act. It’s easy and it works.

      Write a climate review

      Voice your opinion on how businesses and organizations impact the climate.
      0 trees planted

      One tree is planted for every climate review written to an organization that is Open for Climate Dialogue™.

      Download the app

      We plant a tree for every new user.