Climate warning
Image of Justin Trudeau

Justin Trudeau

Climate warning

Canada oil sands air pollution 20-64 times worse than industry says

A recent study has revealed that air pollution levels from Canada’s oil sands operations are up to 64 times higher than industry-reported figures. This alarming discovery underscores the urgent need for accurate emissions monitoring and more stringent environmental regulations. The study, conducted by Environment and Climate Change Canada and Yale University, highlights significant underestimations in current reporting methods, raising serious concerns about the health and environmental impacts of these emissions.
Canada’s oil sands, located in northern Alberta, represent the fourth-largest oil deposit on Earth and are among the most energy-intensive to access and process. Bitumen extraction from the oil sands involves both open-pit and in-situ mining techniques, producing 3.3 million barrels per day. Current industry methods for calculating air pollution rely on a "bottom-up" approach, which has proven to be grossly inaccurate.



Key Findings
Significant Underreporting of Emissions: The study found that oil sands operations emit between 20 and 64 times more air pollution than reported by industry. Real-time measurements using aircraft-based sensors revealed that emissions from oil sands facilities account for approximately 1% of extracted petroleum, equating to the total organic carbon emissions from all other sources across Canada combined.
Health and Environmental Risks: The pollutants emitted, including volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and intermediate and semi-volatile organic compounds (I/SOVs), are known to have severe health impacts. These include respiratory and cardiovascular issues, cancer, endocrine disruption, and cognitive effects. The study's findings suggest that the total air pollution from oil sands is comparable to that found in large American cities like Los Angeles.
Inadequate Current Reporting Methods: Industry-reported emissions are calculated using a bottom-up approach that fails to account for all sources of pollution. The real-time aerial measurements used in the study provide a more accurate depiction of the true extent of emissions, revealing major discrepancies in current reporting practices.
Impact on Indigenous Communities: Indigenous communities near the oil sands, such as the Fort McKay First Nation, are experiencing significant health impacts due to prolonged exposure to multiple pollutants. Concerns about air quality and health have long been dismissed by referencing inaccurate industry reports.
Policy Implications: The inaccuracies in emissions reporting have serious implications for policy and decision-making. Models used to predict the impacts of new projects rely on accurate data; without it, policy decisions may be based on misleading information, potentially exacerbating environmental and health issues.
Recommendations
Improve Emissions Monitoring: Adopt more accurate real-time measurement techniques for monitoring air pollution from oil sands operations. Implement mandatory use of aircraft-based sensors or similar technologies to ensure comprehensive data collection.
Strengthen Regulations: Revise environmental regulations to reflect the true scale of emissions. Introduce stricter limits on allowable emissions and enforce penalties for non-compliance.
Enhance Transparency: Require full transparency in emissions reporting from oil sands operators. Ensure that data is publicly accessible and subject to independent verification.
Protect Vulnerable Communities: Implement immediate measures to mitigate the health impacts on Indigenous communities and other populations living near oil sands operations. Increase funding for health studies focusing on long-term exposure to multiple pollutants.
Promote Sustainable Energy: Accelerate the transition to renewable energy sources. Reduce reliance on fossil fuels and invest in sustainable energy infrastructure, including wind and solar power.
The findings of this study are a stark warning that current approaches to monitoring and regulating air pollution from Canada’s oil sands are inadequate. The government must take immediate action to address these issues, protect public health, and fulfill its commitment to environmental sustainability. Failure to act will continue to endanger the health of communities and the environment, undermining efforts to combat climate change.

Do you agree?

21 more agrees trigger contact with the recipient

  • Ann Nyambura

    35 w

    This is incredibly alarming!

    2
    • johnte ndeto

      37 w

      It's deeply concerning that the true extent of air pollution from Canada's oil sands operations has been so severely underestimated.

      4
      • Elizabeth Gathigia

        37 w

        This is very concerning, Canada needs to put strict measures to monitor emissions

        3
        • johnte ndeto

          37 w

          @elizbeth_gathigia it also raises serious questions about their regard for public health and environmental well-being.

          2
        • Matin Ahrimankosh

          37 w

          Shocking! Canada needs stricter emissions monitoring immediately.

          4
          • johnte ndeto

            37 w

            @matin_ahrimankosh The fact that emissions are up to 64 times higher than reported is utterly unacceptable.

            2
          • Kevin

            37 w

            This has reached very concerning levels and it is high time Canada puts up very stringent laws on emissions.

            5
            • johnte ndeto

              37 w

              @Kevin this highlights a glaring failure in current monitoring and reporting systems.

              2
            • Annett Michuki..

              37 w

              this is worsening day by day, something should be done

              7
              • johnte ndeto

                37 w

                @annett_michuki It's appalling that such vital information has been mismanaged, potentially putting countless lives at risk.

                2
              • walter lungayi

                37 w

                They should be ashamed for lying in their report. Addressing this discrepancy is crucial to ensuring accurate data and informing effective policies to mitigate the environmental impact of oil sands operations.

                6
                • johnte ndeto

                  37 w

                  @walter_lungayi it's simply exacerbating environmental degradation.

                  2
                • Rukia Ahmed Abdi

                  37 w

                  This is alarming. Their is a need for Canada to put up strict laws on emission monitoring as well as environmental regulations.

                  12
                  • johnte ndeto

                    37 w

                    @rukia_ahmed_abdi The reliance on inaccurate "bottom-up" approaches underscores a systemic issue that urgently needs to be addressed with more robust monitoring.

                    2
                  • Jane Wangui

                    37 w

                    This calls for accurate emissions monitoring so as to put up appropriate measures to deal with the pollution.

                    9
                    • johnte ndeto

                      37 w

                      @jane_wangui This revelation should serve as a wake-up call for the industry and policymakers to prioritize the health and safety of both people and the planet over profit margins.

                      2
                    • Princess

                      37 w

                      Ignoring these issues will only perpetuate the harm caused to both human health and the environment.

                      13
                      • Rukia Ahmed Abdi

                        37 w

                        @princess_nel_268 I agree with you. Ignorance does not help but increases the harm. Their is need for accuracy and measures to curb pollution

                        6
                        • johnte ndeto

                          37 w

                          @princess_nel_268 I totally agree with you 💯

                          2

                        Watch all the Davos Hub content!

                        Broadcasts

                        Re-watch all our COP29 broadcasts

                        We need to stop methane and #BuyMoreTime